BLOOMBERG LAW

By Samantha Handler

May 23, 2022, 1:15 PM

  • California transfers favor tech giants, litigation conference told
  • Patent owners need favorable facts to keep suits in Texas

Patent owners looking keep their patent infringement lawsuits in Waco’s famously owner-friendly federal court need to focus on the location of witnesses and documents to potentially avoid the Federal Circuit moving the case, attorneys say.

The US Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit has rebuked Alan Albright in a series of orders analyzing his handling of transfer requests. The high concentration of patent litigation in the Western District of Texas has caught the attention of Congress and Chief Justice Roberts, who requested a report, due in May, reviewing the rules that led to the flock of filings in Waco.

The Federal Circuit’s granting of transfers unfairly favors defendants, making it easier now for Silicon Valley companies to use the requests to their advantage, attorneys said at IPWatchdog’s Patent Litigation Masters conference on Monday. Tech giants like Google LLC and Apple Inc. file requests at the Federal Circuit to move cases out of Albright’s court and into the more convenient Northern District of California.

Recent Federal Circuit decisions focus on the location of witnesses and documents when deciding where the proper venue is for a suit, attorneys said. This is a departure from other analyses, where courts consider how convenient a venue is based on how far witnesses must travel, rather than considering the offices or number of personnel a company has in a venue, said Wendy Verlander of Verlander LLP.

Albright’s “hands are tied” now in terms of what he can do to keep cases out of California, Verlander said.

“Convenience analysis is largely flipped on its head,” Verlander said. “These days what’s been happening is looking at where the defendants are. It’s defendant-centric.”

Miranda Y. Jones, at patent litigator at Port Hedges, said there’s enough guidance now from the Federal Circuit for patent owners to anticipate the alleged infringers’ arguments.

“If you’re a patent owner, you need to do your homework,” Jones said during the panel. “There’s a lot of information out there, and you can get a good sense of what their argument is going to be before you file the complaint.”

Erick Robinson, the intellectual property co-chair at Spencer Fane LLC in Texas, said the fight for patent owners to prevent transfer of cases out of Texas can be the decisive factor in the case.

“This is as important as trial,” Robinson said. “If you lose you are going to California and your patents are going to die.”