LAW360

(January 25, 2022, 8:49 PM EST) — In the last few months of 2021, no patent owners were able to escape Patent Trial and Appeal Board reviews because related litigation was moving quickly in the Eastern or Western District of Texas, according to data presented at an IPWatchdog conference Tuesday.

While the Texas courts have built up a reputation for getting to trial quickly, that has not been able to help patent owners persuade the PTAB to issue discretionary denials of reviews of their patents, according to Buchanan Ingersoll & Rooney PC partner Todd Walters. The data was pulled from Docket Navigator for a Tuesday panel at the PTAB Masters 2022 conference, which asked “Has the WDTX Been Neutered?”

The discretionary denial policy at issue is referred to as Fintiv, based on the case that made it precedential. Under Fintiv, administrative patent judges look at factors like the timing of co-pending litigation and whether that litigation is stayed to determine whether their review would unnecessarily duplicate work done in district court.

“Based on the data set that we have, it appears that maybe you can get a Fintiv denial outside of the Eastern District of Texas or Western District of Texas. Maybe you can, maybe you can’t,” Global IP Law Group partner Alison Richards, who represents patent owners, said. “That’s a very curious thing because I think everyone’s experience is that places like Delaware and places like the Northern District of California have traditionally been much, much slower getting to trial.”

Clockwise from top left, Global IP Law Group’s Alison Richards, Verlander LLP’s Wendy Verlander, Dentons‘s Kevin Greenleaf, IPWatchdog’s Gene Quinn, Ropes & Gray‘s Scott McKeown and Buchanan Ingersoll & Rooney PC’s Todd Walters on a PTAB Masters 2022 panel Tuesday.


The Texas courts are still attractive to patent owners, with Judge Alan Albright in the Western District getting claim construction handled early in the case, limiting discovery and getting to trial quickly, but the districts may not be as useful in invoking discretionary denials as the IP community expects, the panelists said.

“If it’s a Fintiv argument alone, you can’t beat IPR institution — at least right now — by filing in the Eastern District or the Western District of Texas alone,” Richards said. “You need something else.”


Wendy Verlander of Verlander LLP, who also represents patent owners, was quick to point out that while the data is “stark,” it only covers a few months, and that Fintiv denials were down across the board, not just in Texas.

“I’m not sure I would declare Fintiv completely dead at this point,” she said.

Part of that, however, may be judges waiting to see what the next U.S. Patent and Trademark director will do. Ropes & Gray LLP’s Scott McKeown suggested judges don’t want to risk having to deal with a bunch of rehearings because the director chooses to get rid of Fintiv.

“I wonder how much of it is [PTAB judges] trying to get out in front of a potential bubble of cases that might be sitting there — that were denied under Fintiv — that should the policy change, the judges are going to have to do some rework,” McKeown said.

Some decline in denials may be due to petitioners getting smarter, Kevin Greenleaf of Dentons said. Now that Fintiv has been in place for more than a year, petitioners have figured out how to adjust their litigation strategy accordingly, he said. For example, there’s an increasing reliance on stipulations, in which the petitioners say they won’t raise grounds that were brought to the PTAB, or reasonably could have been, in district court.

IPWatchdog’s Gene Quinn and former USPTO Director Andrei Iancu discuss Fintiv at the PTAB Masters 2022 on Tuesday. Display errors altered their coloring.

Before the panel began, the conference aired an interview between IPWatchdog founder Gene Quinn and former USPTO Director Andrei Iancu, now an Irell & Manella LLP partner. The director who set Fintiv in motion claims petitioners shouldn’t get challenges at both the district court and PTAB unless there’s good reason.

“The PTAB should act with humility and restraint in the face of [an] adjudication that already took place in the district court,” Iancu said. “The petitioner has their choice — if [you] want a district court adjudication, [you] can have it, but not the PTAB. If you want the PTAB adjudication, you can have it as long as you tell us that you’re not going to repeat the same exact arguments at the district court. Just pick one … Who are you helping by mandating that you get a second bite of the apple?”

The panelists concluded that the change in how often Fintiv is ending patent challenges early hasn’t “neutered” the Western District of Texas. Judge Albright has around a quarter of the country’s new patent litigation filed in his court, and suits are still being filed with him.

“The thing clients want is certainty. On the plaintiff’s side, Judge Albright gives some certainty to get to trial in a fairly reasonable amount of time,” Buchanan Ingersoll’s Walters said. “The icing on that cake was discretionary denials.”

McKeown of Ropes & Gray added that the Western District of Texas has been “a victim of its own success.” Judge Albright has been amassing a patent docket in the Waco division — where he is the only district court judge — and doing so has placed scrutiny on him. Judge Albright is a former patent litigator who has been vocal about his desire and ability to handle patent cases.

Without directly naming Judge Albright, Congress complained to the judiciary that the court system was configured in such a way that companies could decide which judge would oversee patent cases, which led to Chief Justice John Roberts calling for a Judicial Conference review into what needs to change to ensure random assignment of judges.

“Regardless of what happens at the PTAB, I think those practices there are bound to change,” McKeown said. “If the Judicial Conference isn’t going to do something to make the optics of that change drastically, then I think you’re going to see legislation.”

–Editing by Gemma Horowitz.