LAW360

By Britain Eakin

Law360 (May 23, 2022, 9:16 PM EDT) — Patent owners wanting to avoid mandamus orders from the Federal Circuit and keep infringement suits in the Western District of Texas need to be more aggressive in venue-related discovery, according to a panel of attorneys who said the Federal Circuit is eager to steer cases away from Judge Alan Albright’s courtroom.

The Federal Circuit has repeatedly rebuked Judge Albright for how he analyzes various factors when defendants file motions to transfer out of his rocket docket in Waco, Texas. The appeals court has ruled that Judge Albright — who oversees the nation’s busiest patent docket — abused his discretion to keep several cases in his district, criticizing, in part, how he assesses the convenience of witnesses.

It appears the Federal Circuit is looking to overhaul Judge Albright’s transfer analysis and come up with a different outcome, according to Wendy Verlander, managing partner of Verlander LLP who spoke on a panel at the Patent Litigation Masters conference sponsored by the legal blog IP Watchdog.

“The convenience analysis has been flipped on its head,” Verlander said of the court’s mandamus orders.

The panel, called “The CAFC vs. Texas: Mandamus and the Battle Over Venue,” had plenty of criticism for the Federal Circuit’s heavy hand. But the speakers also put forth some suggestions for plaintiffs as they navigate venue fights in the Western District of Texas.

The Federal Circuit has said in its mandamus orders that Judge Albright is prone to overlooking the location of defendant witnesses.

Plaintiffs should look into whether witnesses invoked by defendants to get infringement suits against them transferred ever get deposed or end up testifying, according to panelist David Henry, who is based in Waco and heads Gray Reed’s intellectual property litigation practice group. Henry’s firm is researching the matter now to determine whether that serves a legitimate basis for the Federal Circuit to order transfers, he said.

Though the research project is still in its early stages, Henry said early indications suggest some defendants might be gaming the system to get their cases moved out of the Western District of Texas.

Once findings are solidified, the research could go a long way toward bolstering plaintiffs’ efforts to combat transfer motions, according to panelist Erick Robinson, a Houston-based partner at Spencer Fane LLP who co-chairs the firm’s intellectual property practice group. But he said there are steps plaintiffs can take in the meantime.

Plaintiffs need to take advantage of the venue-related discovery Judge Albright has permitted in response to the Federal Circuit’s rebukes, he said, adding that they should focus on sussing out the heart of Henry’s research: the number of times defendants have moved to transfer infringement suits against them out of the Western District of Texas.

Plaintiffs should then examine whether, in those earlier cases, the non-Texas based witnesses whom defendants point to in order to argue that their preferred venue is more convenient ever actually got deposed in those cases, Robinson said.

“Judge Albright has a default limit on the number of deposition hours for venue discovery, but if we have a good faith basis for wanting to talk to a reasonable number of people, we’ll probably be able to do it,” Robinson said.

The Federal Circuit also has chided Judge Albright for discounting the location of physical evidence, even when that evidence is electronically stored.

Parties in the Western District of Texas therefore need to focus on the location of documentary evidence, according to Verlander.

She called it “mind-blowing” that in this day and age, the appeals court is still insisting that factor be weighed based on the location of paper documents when documents can be moved now by “pressing a button.”

It used to be the case that trucks would transport hundreds of thousands of pages of documentary evidence, she said, calling that scenario “truly inconvenient.”

–Additional reporting by Ryan Davis and Dani Kass. Editing by Lakshna Mehta.